Author

The Curry Critics

Browsing

You could walk past this place, ostensibly a takeaway kebab house, without realising the true gem that lies inside. The terrace blackboards advertise their almuerzo and, at the appropriate time a reasonably priced menu del día (7.95€). But nowhere does it advertise what a rich lode there is waiting for those who venture inside the doorway to this ‘cafe takeaway’.

For our latest review we decided to test the ‘unconventional’; in reality, a typical cafe that you might find in any British city with a big population of ethnic Southern Asians.

We had been told the tandoor was good here. So we booked by phone, asked for extra spicy seekh kebabs and chicken tandoori. They were very accomodating, even to the point of advising us they only had red wine available but agreeing very readily that we could take our own white wines without charge. For the record, there are beer and fizzy drinks as well.

When we arrived we were shown to our table, offered a drink, given the menu and they checked that it was us who had ordered our first courses. So far so good!

We had taken our own white wine, Silencio, a dry moscatel from the co-op in Godelleta (6€.) This is very fresh, quite fruity and has the perfect balance of acidity. It matched all of the dishes.

While we had our beers and cokes we chose our main courses for later and the accompanying breads and rice. There are no papadoms, so don’t expect these to arrive un-announced!

It is a cafe inside, somewhere to sit whilst you wait for your takeaway but there are currently three tables for 5 people spread out. There are the odd pictures that remind you of the Indian sub-continent but the main ones are above the takeaway counter and illustrate the kebab options. Hey, we don’t go for the decor, we want good food!

The waiter was friendly and took our order and checked what level of spicing was wanted for the curries and this was checked by the owner before they cooked it.

There are probably around half the range of dishes of many restaurants, mainly chicken and lamb or vegetarian. There is not a lot of rice to order, but a good range of breads. (And wait for what we have to tell you later!)

On this occasion we have to record Marian and Nitu were unable to attend but Matt and Riki were joined by Erica and Julie, Americans with an experience of Indian food in the USA, here and a wide range of knowledge of spiced foods worldwide.

We ordered for starters extra spicy chicken tandoori and Seekh kebabs. The chicken , well, no hiding this, was the best we have ever tasted! Moist, tender, well-spiced, well-charred and served with a sweet/sour tamarind sauce, smoky with ginger, plenty of heat and a simple yoghurt sauce. Somewhere in ordering there was a breakdown in translation or a simple mistake and the kebab that arrived was wrapped in a durum with salad and a sauce. But, we didn’t send it back because when we unwrapped it the scents that emerged drove us all to dig in. The flavour was incredible, the meat tender and very tasty. Clearly this is a kebab house with a difference!

For mains we ordered Lamb achuri, Chicken Jalfrezi and aloo saag (potato and spinach). This was to be accompanied with a pilao rice, plain naan, cheese and garlic naan and a stuffed paratha.

We had asked for the lamb dish to be extra spicy and were not disappointed. The meat was chunky, tasty and tender, the sauce had the correct level of heat which did not mask the flavours of the spices and especially that slightly bitter finish that you expect in a well-cooked dish.

The chicken Jalfrezi was ‘normal’ i.e. for the Spanish taste but once again it was perfectly balanced, soft tender chicken, pepper and tomato flavour. The aloo saag was a creamy, flavourful spinach sauce with soft potato, again well-balanced flavour. All three dishes were colour free, clearly identifiable and a real pleasure to eat.

The plain naan was very good, fluffy, with a crispy exterior and with that elasticity you want to see. The cheese naan was missing the garlic but apart from that was just as good. The paratha was not stuffed but it was the crispiest, layered, fluffiest paratha we have had…undoubtedly the best anywhere in Valencia, truly authentic.

It is most unusual to write a separate paragraph about the rice! This is to die for! Fried with spices, we identified cumin seed and black cardamom, almost certainly in butter like a pilaf with the tiniest hints of green pepper. A vegetarian would feast on this dish alone!

We ordered a mixed dessert dish of gulab jamun, jalebi, milk cake, carrot halwa and yellow gram flour halwa.

The size of portions was perfect. We were all full without feeling ‘stuffed’, there was nothing to put in a doggy bag! The quality of the food we were served was excellent. Yes there were two or three errors but did we care…no we did not because they did not detract from the overall experience! Would we go back?… Tomorrow!

So, if it’s authentic food you want this is one of the best places in the city. If it’s ambience (decoration etc.) you will be disappointed. It’s a takeaway kebab house with an incredibly well-hidden secret inside!

The overall service was good, errors forgiven, the place was actually full (mainly ethnic South Asian families) with takeaways going out and people on the terrace. The coffee machine wasn’t working but the waiter went to a cafe nearby to get them. That is service.

The overall bill came to 60€ adjusted for the bottle of wine we took it worked out at 17€ per person which makes it amongst the best for quality to price ratio.

And our overall score has to reflect the authenticity and quality of food, but balance it against the ambience and minor errors in an otherwise perfect service.

We score Lahore Tandoori 8.5/10. Up there with the best! Do go and try it, you really won’t be disappointed.

Our Rating: 8.5/10

Cúrcuma is a relatively new Indian Restaurant in Avenida Joan Carles a bright, airy modern restaurant with equally colourful decorations.

In the absence of Nitu on family grounds, we were accompanied by Sunnil (Khetosa Vegetables) and his wife Anna on our visit on Saturday evening, 27 November.

There is a good range of wines from Valencia (Nodus) and Portia (Ribera del Duero) and we opted for ‘En la Parra’ from Nodus (DO Valencia)—a blend of Chardonnay and Moscatel—which we knew should be a good match for spicy food; it was. The blend of fruit and acidity was perfect and stood up to even the hottest dish. At 11€ a bottle this was a markup of just 2€ on the bodega price, the best we have come across to date.

We received a pleasant and friendly welcome, were shown to our table and handed the menu cards and the wine list.

Cúrcuma has a big menu to choose from including half a dozen recommended dishes, one of which we chose.

Although we were not advised on what to order, the waiter showed great flexibility allowing us to have our own mixed grill from the tandoor comprising of Haryali Chicken, Lamb Achari, Seekh Kebabs and Chicken Tikka. We also ordered King Prawn on Puri and an Onion Bhaji as starters.

We were quickly served with good-sized, tasty papadums with the standard chutney sauces but as we ordered a second plate of these we were given an additional hot lime pickle chutney that was very good.

The onion bhajis were good, tasty and with a very good texture and flavoured with anise seed. The prawn on puri was a good size, although the sauce was a little too strong on tomato and light on spice, the puri was crisp and light and the prawns full of flavour and cooked well.

On the downside, the special mixed grill was disappointing. It appears the meat had been pre-cooked, leading to all of it being dry, lacking in any flavour, spice or heat.

For main courses, we ordered paneer karahi, beef bhuna, lamb phall and chicken pasanda: the ‘chef´s recommended dish’. These were accompanied by plain basmati rice, a cheese naan, garlic naan and a paratha.

The paneer karahi (cheese in a tomato, garlic, ginger and spicy sauce) was again a little high on the tomato side, the cheese a little rubbery.

The beef bhuna (a similar sauce with additional coriander and onion) suffered from being overcooked , with tough beef chunks and a lack of seasoning in the sauce.

The lamb phall was hot, but not extremely hot as we had been advised when ordering. The lamb was dry and overcooked. The sauce was clearly full of either cayenne or chili powder and it was overdone to the extent it caught in the back of the throat.

The chicken pasanda (a sauce made with almonds, coconut, and a cocktail of fruits) again suffered from overcooked chicken breast; the sauce was lacking in spice and was indeed very fruity and sweet.

All of the meat was disappointing, pre-cooked and as a result, had not taken any flavour from the accompanying spices and sauces.

On the other hand, the basmati rice was good, the cheese naan crispy with plenty of tasty cheese oozing from it, and the garlic naan was also good: crispy and with good garlic worked into it. The paratha was more like a roti, a flatbread, lacking in the layers we expected and not how it is described on the menu.

We finished with a couple of ice-creams, Mango Kulfi and a Pista Kulfi (Pistachio).

Of these, we preferred the Pista Kulfi which was grainy in texture with good flavour from the milk and cream—a good example. The Mango Kulfi was more fruity and less on the cream and milk flavour, but not bad at all.

In all cases the size of portions was good, and the service was efficient and friendly. The standard of cooking was mixed; the presentation and appearance of the dishes very good but the meat and the sauces left a lot to be desired.

The bill—which included two bottles of wine—came to 97.50€ or just under 20€ per head and Cúrcuma has the potential (If the cooking improves) to be good value for money. At present we would score them at 5.5/10.

Our Rating: 5.5/10

On 27 October the Curry Critics set out for a meal in Royal Budhha, a Nepali Indian Restaurant in Calle Ciscar in the heart of Valencia’s city nightlife. On this occasion, Nitu sat out the meal as she has been arranging a Diwali event there, and to preserve our independence it was felt better if the rest of us went anonymously. We invited Videk, an independent Indian foodie to join us.

Royal Buddha is clean and bright when you enter and we were given a very good welcome by the waiter who had, it turned out, only worked there a couple of days. We were shown to our table and offered drinks, ordering a bottle of Marina Alta (dry Moscatel from Bodegas Bocopa in DO Alicante)

The attention by our waiter as we ordered was outstanding. He gave us helpful advice, recommended a couple of dishes and offered us different levels of spiciness and heat for what we eventually chose to eat. Nothing seemed to be too much to ask!

The menu has upwards of 150 dishes and a very reasonable wine list where the markup is between 200% on the cheaper wines but not more than 50% on the most expensive.

The family running the restaurant are Nepali in origin and there was a birthday party at the far end of the dining area where the kids were celebrating without affecting the experience of others. Nepali food is different in some aspects from Northern and Southern Indian or Pakistani dishes so we were looking forward to seeing how the dishes compared with other Nepali restaurants where we have eaten independently in the past. It would be fair to say we were not disappointed generally!

We ordered three starters to follow the papadums and chutneys (4) which were fairly standard. The Prawn on Puri was adequate, not the biggest, but sufficient, the sauce lacking some heat and the prawns not the freshest. The Seekh kebabs were a little dry and to some a little too firm again lacking in heat but we were spoiled in Lal Qila! The momo-C (a Nepali and Indian variety of the Japanese Gyozo and Chinese dumpling) were interesting. They consist of a meat patty inside the flour-based covering which are then boiled or steamed and which were served with a hotter version of the sauce accompanying the Prawn on Puri. we all noted white onions rather than red had been included in both sauces.

The tandoor is a ‘harsh mistress’ and the seekh kebabs could simply have been the result of overcooking. Nitu had eaten there on a previous occasion and had found them to be very good.

Matt found the Momos to be very tasty, something we would all agree on.

For the main courses we chose Nepali Lamb Sekuwa, Haryali chicken, Lamb saag and the fourth dish was to be a surprise, asking for something the chef wanted to showcase. It turned out to be a Methi Chicken. Two were ordered mild and the other two with a degree more heat.

The four of us would say the dishes were all excellent, with a completely different range of flavours and spicing.

Haryali chicken is now a firm favourite and one of our reference dishes. Having complained on a previous occasion about the lack of mint in the green sauce it was somewhat an irony that if anything the mint was too powerful on this occasion. The meat was beautifully tender and moist but could have done with a bit more charring…..again a matter of seconds in the tandoor.

The Methi chicken was cooked well with Nepali spices, the sauce was tasty and it made an interesting contrast to the usual masala we include!

The two lamb dishes were outstanding. The lamb saag was very tasty, tender and creamy and Marian found this to be her favourite. The Lamb Sekuwa was large chunks of tender tandoori Lamb, well-grilled and not charred, which were an eye-opener. There was a spicy curry sauce to go with the Haryali and the Sekuwa which was very well made.

Collectively this was the best set of main courses we have enjoyed anywhere and consistently well-cooked with the widest variation of flavours. We may have liked a slightly higher degree of spicing or heat but there were no complaints.

They were accompanied by a plain naan, the fluffiest and most authentic we have tasted, a cheese naan which oozed its interior and was very tasty, and a pilau rice coloured with saffron and spiced with cumin seeds.

The portion size was good, we finished almost everything except for a bit of rice.

The ambience was fine (Nitu even got to choose the music when she went) and she highly rates the dry chicken chili which is one of the house specials. The restaurant and its toilets were clean and overall service was a 10/10.

Next time I think we would choose the most expensive white wine , the Anma White (Garnacha Blanca) from Chozas Carrascal (DO Utiel Requena) but the Marina Alta worked well with the flavours of the food we ordered.

Price-wise for a restaurant in the city centre it scores highly, we paid 27€ a head which included two bottles of wine.

We would definitely recommend Royal Buddha and award an 8/10 score. This was a real pleasure.

Our Rating: 8/10

Monal (Pheasant) is an Indian/Pakistani restaurant in C/Juan Llorens, run by two brothers Akil and Nadeem. It has a strong following and Nitu has taken a group from Valencia Curry Lovers there for a meal before and independently Marian and Riki had also eaten there not long after it first opened. Neither Matt nor our guest Sid from Khetosa Vegetable Boxes had previously eaten there.

We visited on Sunday evening, a quiet evening in the restaurant as it turned out.

We received a friendly welcome and they happily enlarged our reserved table inside to give us more space. There is terrace seating as well. The menu is relatively small with 67 dishes. It has a separate wine list with around a dozen wines including a good representation of Valencian wines from La Viña, the Cooperative in La Font de la Figuera. (Icono, Juan de Juanes and Venta del Puerto).

We ordered a bottle of Verdeo Verdejo, a 2020 Rueda from Torres. Clean and bright, fresh and youthful with a yellow colour. Fragrant on the nose, and fresh, with citric and tropical notes in the mouth. (12€)

This accompanied the papadums and the starters. Monal has a wider range of chutney’s and we were presented with five, the best of which was undoubtedly an awesome lime pickle, almost unique in Valencia!

For starters we ordered Vegetable Pakora, Seekh Kebab, Shami Kebab, and a chicken tikka. Of these, the Chicken tikka was undoubtedly the best, well-spiced, moist and tender and served sizzling. The shami kebab had too much egg for our taste. The Pakoras were crispy, the texture suggested mashed potato in the mix rather than small cubes and they were a little dense. The seekh kebabs were also excellent, good texture and spice and good meaty flavour underlying.

The wine whilst good did not have quite enough body and flavour to stand up to the spicing in the food.

The ambience was ok, the music in the background good and the aircon was good. But it is not a restaurant where the smell of spice hits you as you walk in!

For main courses we ordered Lamb with Okra, Butter chicken, Chicken Madras, Garlic and cheese naan, Peshwari naan, Kulcha naan and a Basmati Special Rice.

To accompany this we tried a Rosado, Santa Digna Cabernet Sauvignon from Torres but this time from their Chilean Central Valley vineyards. Quite a deep strawberry colour it has an expressive bouquet, lots of ripe fruit such as strawberry and plum with a citrus (grapefruit) note. In the mouth this had a lovely balance between the fruit and the acidity and a persistent finish. It not only balanced the spice in the food but enhanced the enjoyment of the meal. This is highly recommended! (14€)

The lamb with okra was the best of the main courses, the lamb chunky and tender, the okra well cooked (no slime) and the spicing correct (we asked for this to be medium spiced). The butter chicken was good, but could have done with a little more spice, our fault for asking this to be at a level aimed at Spanish customers. The Chicken Madras (with the highest heat option) was the disappointing dish and the least typical Madras we have tasted so far. It just lacked flavour and there was an underlying ‘oily ‘ sensation which was not ghee.

Matt felt that there was insufficient delineation between the flavours of the lamb and chicken madras and Nitu pointed out that where a restaurant uses a mother sauce and then adds a specific sauce to give the dish its spice profile, it has to be a very good sauce and if it is it can work perfectly. Equally of course if there is a problem with the mother sauce it will be carried into all the dishes.

Of the breads, The garlic naan with cheese was good, the flaky, fresh garlic full of flavour, it could have done with a little more cheese maybe. The Peshwari naan was nice , coming with dried fruit (mainly raisins) which we repeated later, the second having more dried apricot, quite different! The rice was standard with a mix of colours, but the Kulcha Naan was again disaapointing Nitu has had this before and previously enjoyed it but on this occasion, they had used flaked dry chili rather than fresh and it didn’t work well.

Probably because it was a Sunday evening the only dessert option was ice-cream, either Mango or Pistachio Kulfi.

The service was good, if understated. We were offered spicing (heat) options, we were advised when we had ordered enough, and the waiter engaged with our comments.

However in our overall view we were a little underwhelmed, those who had eaten there before feeling they had had better previous experiences. The portions were not tiny but did seem on the small side. But we did order more or less the usual amount of dishes and there were pieces of naan left at the end. We felt they had not paid sufficient attention to the spicing in the main dishes apart from the lamb.

The total cost was just over 26€ a head (a couple of gin-tonics, a coffee and water were included) The wine mark-up—discounting supermarket offers—was around 100% which is less than many other restaurants. A takeaway service is available. ‘Price to Value Ratio’ was average but clearly had one or two of the dishes been better this would be above average.

Overall it was not a bad meal and we would all return.

Our Rating: 6.5/10

Swagat (or Welcome) is a chain of Indian Restaurants in Valencia and L’Eliana is the latest addition to the two in Valencia City. The restaurant in Conde Altea has a strong and loyal following and is often one of the most widely recommended Indian eateries on internet forums for its consistent output.

This third and newest outlet in L’Eliana opened about a month ago with a fanfare of advance publicity. It was with some reasonable expectations that we decided to visit today, 9 September, having heard it has been packed to the rafters. Indeed we arrived just after it opened at 13.30 to find five tables already full with diners. Booking is advised therefore if you want to go.

The restaurant has tables both inside and out and we chose a table inside by a window. The welcome was fine, the staff very polite and we were given ample time to order our food and drinks.

The range of food is extensive and the full menu can be downloaded from their website so you can see what you can order in advance. There is also a large drinks range, with lassi’s, beers (including Cobra), spirits and a big wine list. We ordered a pint of draft beer (lager), a tonic water and a bottle of the house wine, currently Matarromera Melior Verdejo from Rueda. The wine was fruity, with good volume and good acidity, proving to be a perfect match with the food. It is sold by the glass and the bottle. It sells for 13€ a bottle, (around six online).

The wine list is also quite extensive and expensive, with the most pricy bottles which will cost you 42€ which is more than just a little pretentious. Swagat clearly has some intention to be a fine dining experience. But if that is your aspiration the food has to be very good as well.

It would be fair to say that this was by far our most disappointing meal to date.

For starters we had ordered Jhinga Puri (prawn on puri), a special mixed tikka, seekh kebabs, Tandoor roti and plain naan. We received no advice or recommendations on house specialities.

Two papadums arrived first, big and crispy and with three bland chutney´s.

The Jhinga Puri was probably the smallest we have ever seen, about one bite per person shared between the four of us. The presentation was nice, the puri curled up correctly at the edges like a basket and the sauce was adequately spiced with a nice dusting of sesame seed, but the puri was too thick and tasted of uncooked dough, the one prawn each overcooked and rubbery.

The special mixed tikka from the tandoor is two large pieces each of chicken breast with three spice dressings: tikka, haryali and parahi. The Haryali was overcooked, dry, and missing some of the spices: the Parahi was probably the best of a bad job it had the best spicing and the yoghurt had stopped it drying out. The chicken tikka was red…dry and oh, so not what we expected.

The seekh kebabs were definitely the worst ever. A pale mustard colour, they had the texture of the worst frozen English sausages with no meat, just rusk, dry, tasteless and overcooked in the oven. They could not be a bigger contrast to the excellent version we had enjoyed in Lal Qila last time out. Moreover, when we complained we were met first with being ignored and the second time with a shrug of the shoulders.

The breads were adequate: the roti a little dry and the naan not quite as fluffy as might be expected from the tandoor.

For main courses we ordered Murgh Malai Methi (Chicken with a fenugreek sauce and almonds), Chicken Vindaloo, Chili Chicken, and Lamb Rogan Josh (lamb in a tomato sauce). To accompany we had plain basmati rice, cheese naan, and a chili, cheese and coriander naan.

The Murgh Malai was probably the most flavourful of the dishes although the sauce was a little gloopy! The chicken was dry, however; something which was also true of the lamb rogan josh…certainly not the tenderest we have had and the sauce lacked identity. The vindaloo had no flavour of vinegar, yes it was hot but the heat was all cayenne pepper powder which masked any other saving grace it might have had. The chili chicken (one of those Indian/Chinese fusion dishes with soy sauce and green pepper) had to be sent back originally as it was cold but on its return, this had nice flavour. We all liked it.

The cheese naan was good, the chili, coriander and cheese naan was bursting with flavour.

Nitu finished with a Kulfi which she would recommend to anyone!

There is no complaint about portion size, there was plenty of food, but the quality (and that is down to the cooking) leaves a lot to desire at the moment.

The ambience is mixed. It is clean, fresh, has high ceilings, the aircon works well. But the walls are bare and when full it was like a Valencian bar; sound bouncing off the walls and difficult to hold a conversation if you can’t hear what is being said! The toilets (which we dont normally comment on) get 10/10 for cleanliness.

In the end, they conceded that there had been poor food and apart from the mango lassi (on the house) they did offer us a 20% discount on the overall bill which came to 92€ and which we acknowledge as an honest gesture, it does however not of itself improve food quality and we genuinely hope they can improve this aspect of the service.

L’Eliana is an affluent suburb of Valencia and can well support a good Indian fine dining experience but at the moment it falls well short of that aim. Currently, we could not give it more than 5/10 as an overall score. Currently, the price to quality ratio is low. (This review only covers Swagat L’Eliana. We have not visited the other outlets in the City and have no comment to make on their ambience, service or food quality.)

Our Rating: 5/10

Lal Qila (the Red Fort) is a barely known Indo/Pakistani outlet in Patraix, on C. Gaspar Aguilar. It is not a restaurant, rather more a ‘dabha’ which is a casual ‘drop in’ eatery serving snacks but they offer a wide range of dishes and we recommend you try them soon!

Don’t expect a hug from the waiter when you arrive, nor even a cheery smile! It just isn’t that sort of place. Its all about the food!

The lack of welcome was largely followed by a lack of advice when ordering from the menu although we think sometimes this can be because we are confident when ordering our meals. Nitu had visited a couple of times before so knew some of the specialities of the house and ordered these to start with. We were joined this time by Deep and his partner Giulia who are responsible for ‘Valencia Activities’, an events organisation.

To be fair we were asked if we wanted the food spiced up and if we wanted to sit in or out ( we recommend inside as Gaspar Aguilar is a busy main road) and the waiter showed flexibility in cooking us papadums especially (they are not on the menu) even making us chutney`s to go with them and allowing us to bring in our own drinks (as devout muslims they do not serve alcohol).

(For the record the Chinese owned bar next door does an excellent Verdejo called ‘Candium’ from Rueda and the bodega Cuatro Rayas who make a range of very good wines. This was no exception , fresh, fruity with a good acidity it accompanied all the dishes we had as well. 10€ a bottle and no corkage was charged. The Aguila double malt ale at 1.50€ a bottle also worked well.)

If all this sounds a little removed from your idea of a good evening out do not be put off, we simply record the facts as they are. Put aside your prejudices and come with us on a glorious tour of their menu!

Apart from the Indian menu, they also do pizzas and kebabs for takeaway or eat in. The menu is therefore extensive, although a little light on vegetarian dishes.

Following the papadums we tried their vegetable samosas, which were excellent, good pastry, well filled and spicy, for once we noted the ‘amchur’ (mango powder) which gives them a slightly sour flavour. These were followed by the best Seekh kebabs , large, crispy on the outside with a lovely soft inside, very well spiced, tasty beef and absolutely delicious. So good we had two each!

After the palate teasers, we had ordered their house speciality for starters: pollo asado, which is a whole spiced chicken cooked in the tandoor. This may have had a few seconds too long in the oven for some but the meat was tender, the outside exquisitely spiced, and you could taste the lemon. At 8.50€ this is amazing value for money!

This was followed by another house speciality. Lal Qila has 15 fish dishes on their menu, very unusual if not unique. Ours was a whole seabass, baked in the tandoor. This is to die for! The skin holds all the spice flavour with hints of ginger , was crisp and a pleasure by itself. The bones slid out in one piece leaving the most moist fillets of fish that tasted wondefully fresh.

Both the chicken and the fish were sufficient as starters for the six of us but the fish would make a great course in itself for one or two people. With these two dishes we tried the Keema naan, well filled, tasty, spicy (and the bread was excellent) and a potato naan which was also good but not to everyone’s taste.

A fresh kachumber salad followed, red onion, green chili and a simple fresh lemon juice and salt dressing.

As usual we had a run around some of their main course curries. We ordered a mutton Karahi, a chicken vindaloo, a chicken muglai, a palak paneer and cheese naan. No rice was deemed necessary!

The size of the mains were a little smaller than usual but then they were a euro or two cheaper as well. The vindaloo had sliced chicken as did the muglai but this was very tender. The vindaloo despite being advertised as very hot, wasn’t. The Muglai sauce itself was a little dissapointing and not really a substitute for a pasanda. The mutton karahi was fine, with good tender chunks though again lacking a bit of heat.

The Palak (spinach and cheese) was initially disappointing and salty but without complaint was changed and the replacement was creamy and satisfying.

In terms of ambience it’s a cafe, they are decorating it to give it a better feel but you won’t find white damask table cloths nor will you be paying for them with the food either! The music was good.

The quality of the food overall outweighs any lack of charm in the service which was functional. One waiter did the whole of the evening session but coped well with the ordering and the food kept coming. There is no doubt the chef and the tandoor are the outstanding stars at Lal Qila and the most popular dishes judging by other diners choices. The mains are not as good as the starters but we would all go back again very happily.

In fact, pricing here is generally spot-on, the price-to-quality ratio is as close to a 10 as you can get. The overall bill came to 88€ for the six of us and if you add on what the drinks from next door cost you could call it 18€ per head. We will keep looking for better value for money but we haven’t found it yet. Big satisfying portions from the tandoor are so far the best we have discovered anywhere in Valencia.

In the end, it is all about the food! We give Lal Qila a 7.5 overall score and highly recommend you do not miss out on the tandoori specialities!

Our Rating: 7.5/10

The Curry Critics team met again on Friday 2 July to visit and review one of the four new Indian restaurants to open in Valencia in the last month. We were joined this time by Catherine, Matt’s wife and Sunnil, an Indian living in Valencia who is creating an Indian vegetable delivery service, Khetosa.

We arrived just after the restaurant opened for the evening service, entering as the tilers were leaving. Namaste Pais is at 6, Maestro Rodrigo not far from Campanar bridge. It occupies a good-sized site with a big terrace outside although this is right next to a busy, noisy road.

Namaste Pais is on the site of the old Kang Da Chinese restaurant and is shedding its former identity, conducting works while the restaurant is closed. Part of the extensive inside space is being retiled and was unavailable. We had booked a table for six which was adequately sized. The welcome was a little muted but eventually drinks arrived, including a sweet Lassi. There is a small wine list, (probably inherited from the Chinese predecessor). There are also beers available including Cobra and Kingfisher. We ordered a mix of beers, gin & tonics ( which came with cardamom) and Viña Sol from Torres ( a wine much more suited to Chinese than Indian food.)

By the time we got round to ordering the starters we had a new waiter and received good advice on what we should order over and above a few reference dishes. We were even advised that we had ordered enough food which is a very positive point. The menu is extensive and the restaurant does dishes we have not all seen before but which were well known to Nitu and Sunnil.

From the arrival of the Papadums with their garnishes, mango sauce, mint sauce and an onion chutney it was noticeable that the spice level was somewhat different here, the chutney being positively fiery and very good indeed. At Nitu´s request they knocked up a warm sauce to go with the papadums that was even better! At this point we decided not to ask for additional spices in any dish.

Of the starters the Prawn on Puri was disappointing, although the prawns were fresh the whole dish was small and the sauce had too much concentrated tomato to allow the spice to show through. Sunil felt the dough was a little sour but it was initially fluffed up, dropping as it sat on the table. We asked for an Indian Kachumber salad and got a Spanish one, which was also bland. But there any criticism finished abruptly.

Namaste Pais has a Tandoor and Nitu was in her element. We ordered the Kalmi Kebab ( butterflied chicken drumsticks on the bone), Hyarali tandoori, ( Chicken breast in a green paste of Coriander and ginger) and Lamb Achari Tikka (skewered lamb with spices). All had been properly spiced and marinaded and were served sizzler style. Each of the three dishes was succulent, perfectly cooked, with large tender meat chunks. For the Kalmi we had ordered 1.5 portions so that everyone could try it , demonstrating the flexibility the staff can show and we knew then we were in a potentially, very good restaurant foodwise.

For mains we ordered Chicken Vindaloo (it wasn’t available so they substituted a chicken Phall – correct move!), Palak Paneer(spinach and cheese) Lamb badam pasanda (lamb in almond, coconut and cream sauce), Paneer naan, Peshwari naan, Keema naan and a cheese, chili naan and Pilau rice.

The first thing to say was that there was no evidence of ‘mother sauces’ being used. Each dish had its proper sauce, spiced correctly and the colours were quite distinct without using food colouring to enhance them. The chicken Phall was wonderful, Matt and Riki really praising the heat and the subtle spicing. The Palak paneer could have been a bit fresher green in Sunnil and Nitu’s view, the lamb in the Pasanda was really tender, the sauce creamy, the criticisms, if there were any, were minor.

On the bread front the Cheese and chili and Paneer naans were excellent, the Keema naan lacking flavour, a little dry and too crispy in Marian’s view , the Peshwari naan had the correct amount of coconut without being too sweet and it accompanied the Pasanda very well.

We finished with Gulab jamuns (which were a little doughy and lacking in rose flavour), and mango and pistachio kulfi’s the mango standing out as the best dessert.

The size of portions were perfect and as we have said the waiters were flexible in increasing them where necessary with the appropriate price adjustment of course. If the service was slow to start with, it improved when the food started coming, the wait being because some of the dishes were cooked freshly.

The ambience will improve when the redecorations are finished, We noted that there were a number of Spanish diners who have already found the restaurant and the tandoor dishes are clearly very popular with them.

So, in summary the restaurant is a very worthy addition to Valencia´s Indian options. The drinks list needs a complete overhaul and we have offered VÍ Vid´s services to Narender Singh the manager, the alcohol prices (beer, wines and spirits) were more than a little over-expensive and a smaller markup would stimulate sales once they have a better wine list. The total bill for six came to just under 200€ but when the alcohol is stripped out the food came to just under half that making it a very good price to quality ratio.

All of us agreed that this is a ‘Must go to’ restaurant which we highly recommend especially if you like good Indian Cuisine. It has the potential to become a top restaurant. We will all return and have no doubt the teething difficulties will disappear once the restaurant is into its proper rhythm!

Our Rating: 8.5/10

Sunnil is an Indian living in Valencia who with his business partner Sidharta is creating a vegetable growing business in the fields around Alaquas. The aim is to provide vegetables used in traditional Indian cookery such as Okra (Bhindi), chilis, green pumpkins, cucumbers etc . Many of these currently are shipped through Barcelona and come from Africa, not India. They have a short shelf life and different flavours and properties. Once they are ready to commence distribution we will report further on this new business but we can say now they will have  authentic Indian varieties which  will be fresh and have a longer shelf life and will enhance cookery here because many absorb flavours or are themselves flavour enhancers. The idea will be to sell 5kg, 10Kg and 15Kg boxes of mixed vegetables to the public for collection from distribution points around the city including Rusafa. 

Valencia is seeing major growth with the opening of new Indian and Pakistani restaurants, cafes and take-aways. Facebook pages are full of questions from would-be diners, pictures of meals, critiques and even videos of how to cook this style of food which has its origins across the East from Persia to the sub-continent. 

In order to bring some sense to the choice for diners and to offer a helpful, independent and varied critique the ‘curry critics’ have formed to visit, extensively taste in and offer an overall view of the restaurants of Valencia. We aim to bring you a full review of an ‘outlet’ each month with shorter reports and news items in between. 

Who are the curry critics? 

Nitu Chugani is a Sindhi woman who has lived in Valencia for a long, long time. She hails from a family of foodies, and having lived in various countries has a passion for different cuisines. Her cooking blog just happened by chance, posting pictures of what she cooked on Facebook, and everyone would ask her to share the recipe! 

Her Facebook page Nitu Didi Recipes was a result of those requests. Then came www.nitudidi.com and after she started Valencia Curry Lovers on Facebook doing events for the locals and expats in Asian restaurants, always with a special deal.

Her Indian Restaurants in Valencia Facebook page was a result of too many people asking for a “good authentic” Indian restaurant in Valencia.

Matt Armitage is an English web developer who has lived in a variety of places around the Mediterranean over the last ten years, finally settling on Valencia five years ago. A keen home cook, he has been learning the art of Indian cuisine since he was a teenager. He also gained an insight into Keralan cooking when visiting the region and taking cooking lessons there. Originally hailing from West Yorkshire which is home to a large number of Pakistani, Indian and Bangladeshi immigrants, he grew up spoiled for choice for high quality curry restaurants, and is delighted to see the quality of Valencian curry restaurants gradually improving from the somewhat dire straits it was in five years ago. 

Riki Wigley and Marian Daras are respectively English and Valencian who collectively are VÍ Vid , a project promoting Valencian gastronomy and wines. They judge wine and food competitions, report on culinary and wine events and give wine tastings. Both have a love of curries, have eaten in restaurants across the Valencian Community and as far afield as London. Riki also cooks curries at home and for friends. Both bring an entirely independent and critical eye to and appreciation of the food, surroundings, and service and apply a weighted opinion to each venue. 

What criteria do we use?

Firstly we consider the nature of the business, e.g. takeaway, café or restaurant. 

We value a good welcome and advice. Many restaurants have an extensive range of dishes and we all have our favourites by which we measure the variation between venues. 

Drink is an integral part of enjoying a meal and we will assess the options available and comment accordingly. But, we recognise many establishments are owned by people who do not drink themselves and who therefore do not share this ability to make the happy marriage between the food and drink. Beers, wines and spirits will all be taken into account where possible. 

We also recognise that the prime market for the establishments are Spanish diners, with British and other nationalities forming a much smaller part of the clientele. Thus the base spice level will be lower than many of the latter group prefer. The ability to adapt and provide spicier meals with more chili will be assessed. 

We will consider and report on the size of portion, quality of food and the ambience. Valencia does not have an established ‘fine dining’ group of restaurants unlike London or Madrid. Our reviews recognise this. 

Finally we will give an overall review of the service, and the price to quality ratio, and publish these on our various pages and blogs.

Valencia is seeing major growth with the opening of new Indian and Pakistani restaurants, cafes and takeaways. Facebook pages are full of questions from would-be diners, pictures of meals, critiques and even videos of how to cook this style of food which has its origins across the East from Persia to the sub-continent. 

In order to bring some sense to the choice for diners and to offer a helpful, independent and varied critique the ‘curry critics’ have formed to visit, extensively taste in and offer an overall view of the restaurants of Valencia. We aim to bring you a full review of an ‘outlet’ each month with shorter reports and news items in between. Find out more about the team behind Valencia Curry Lovers and the criteria we use for our reviews.


Our first visit as a group was to ‘Curry Chefs’ which is primarily a takeaway in the Plaza de Concordia in Burjassot. (They deliver to several villages and urbanisations locally). We chose this from a number of options because it has a ‘marmite’ reputation amongst Facebook users. It is a small café style (Nitu described it as like a Dhaba ‘eatery’) where it is possible to eat in and there is a small terrace outside facing the square.

On arrival we were offered the opportunity to sit either inside or out and chose the former. We were able to select a larger table for 6 rather than one for 4 people with no problem. The welcome from the Panjabi family who run the venue could not have been friendlier and they engaged with us throughout the meal with genuine concern that we were enjoying the food. There are well over 100 dishes to choose from as well as seven takeaway selections.

Once seated we were given plenty of time to make a selection of dishes. We ordered a white wine by the bottle to share and a gin and tonic. Although they had run out of tonic a member of staff was despatched quickly to buy some from the supermarket!

Keema samosas at Indian Curry Chefs

The drinks range was limited but this is not surprising as it is primarily a take-away and ordering wine is not usually part of such diners choice. Beers were also available. The available wine was not much to write home about and a bit light for the spicy food.

For starters we ordered papadoms, pakoras, prawn on puri, keema samosa and tandoori mixed grill. The results were mixed. The sauces and chutneys accompanying were light and needed spicing up, the chicken pakoras were nuggets effectively, but the samosas were much better if a little short on keema and the prawn on puri drew a unanimous 10/10 from the four of us. Nitu was pleasantly surprised although she doubted the authenticity of the dish. The rest of us use this as a reference dish as it is on the menu of just about every restaurant in Valencia. Well made as this was it can be excellent. The prawns were succulent and the sauce spicy.

Mixed Grill at Curry Chefs Valencia

Sadly the Tandoori grill did not meet the standard expected although several other ‘diners in’ seemed to enjoy theirs. The meat had not been marinaded, nor had it seen the tandoor. It included prawn pakoras and all had been pan-fried and as a result it was dry. This could and should have been so much better if served as a ‘sizzler’. This is one of Nitu’s reference dishes and she was very disappointed.

For mains, we ordered chicken chutney wala, Badami chicken pasanda, lamb vindaloo, a daal makhani and some side dishes: pilau rice, coconut rice, cheese and Peshwari naans and a tawa roti . As an extra we received an aubergine dish to accompany it.

None of these dishes suit Nitu’s palate. There is a problem in that some restaurants make a mother sauce and then adjust them before serving. Marian, Matt and Riki felt there was sufficient difference between them for the English and Spanish palate.

Curry at Curry Chefs Valencia

Marian particularly enjoyed the Pasanda which was rich and creamy and if anything the coconut rice which accompanied it was a little on the sweet side. The Vindaloo had heat, you could note the vinegar and it was correctly cooked. The Daal Makhani was perfectly creamy and very good and suited Matt’s palate perfectly. The breads were mixed, the cheese naan being the best of the selection but the Peshwari naan was not really like any Nitu or the rest of us have experienced before.

There was considerable flexibility on spicing. The owners recognise they have a growing British clientele who enjoy ‘hotter’ meals. Wherever possible they will add to dishes to recognise this different palate. ( We and they recommend if you like hotter dishes that you ring well in advance to order so that they can make a batch of your chosen dish with the required spice and heat – adding chilli flakes at the last minute is not a solution!)

Naan at Curry Chefs Valencia

Portions were good, you won’t go home hungry! The quality of dishes did vary from the excellent Prawn on Puri to a disappointing Tandoori mixed grill. Overall Marian enjoyed the meal and felt Spanish diners would appreciate the range of flavours. Riki found the dishes had sufficient difference in flavour for both the Spanish and British palate .

The ambience is café-take away in style, not fine-dining restaurant and they have an effective takeaway service which Matt has used several times.

In terms of pricing, we had two bottles of wine and Nitu enjoyed a couple of gin and tonics (3.5€). With all the dishes above the total cost came to 22€ per head which puts the quality to price ratio higher than it might have been.

Finally the overall service was exemplary, the four of us are not easily satisfied and the waitress Simran, who is the daughter of the family could not have been more helpful, friendly, witty and charismatic, accepting our copious advice and recommendations, the adjustments we wanted and other family members also came to listen to our points of view- even if they didn’t entirely understand them. We would recommend it as a takeaway recognising it has limitations as an eat-in venue. (Food preparation is different for takeaway than for restaurants). We understand perfectly why it is popular.
However we would all return, (Even Nitu – for the Prawn on Puri and the gin and tonics) as we all enjoyed the excellent service.

Our Rating: 6.5/10
Array of curries and side dishes